- Any viewer needs to have descriptive information about objects in-world, and the textures on the prims, including the sculpt textures if any. The viewer needs this information to be able to display the object.
- Starting from this, it is easily doable for a person who can code to add a few lines to one of the open source viewers, to not only display, but export this information, thus enabling the person operating this modified viewer to re-upload the textures and reconstruct the object. These are the so-called copybot viewers, or copybots.
- NONE of the so called bot defender systems can protect against copybotting!
Why?
- a perfectly legal client is changed to export textures and prim data, WITHOUT in any way changing how this client reacts to Second Life. So its exporting is not detactable in-world.
- a bot detector placed in a shop is utterly unable to prevent any scanning taking place ELSEWHERE in SL (clothing on av's encountered anywhere in SL, objects rezzed somewhere...)
- In consequence this means that ALL bot protector or bot defendor systems that are bought and placed in shops, only serve to calm the fears of the content creators in SL, fearing copybots. Now, don't misunderstand me, copybotting is a reality. But this exaggerated fear, where does it come from? In most cases this fear is propagated by the marketing of the bot defender systems themselves! They generate an imaginary of hordes of copybotters intent to steal the creator's work. In fact, this is making business with the fear of the ill-informed.
How else can be explained a bot protector system in a clothing shop where none of the clothing exists rezzed, but only inside vendors? Without it rezzed in world, it can not be copybotted. Remember, the copybot viewer only exports the very information ANY viewer needs to have, to be able to display the item...
(Which makes a prim's CONTENT, like all scripting and everything else inside a prim's inventory immune to copybotting, by the way.)
- To keep the fear alive and present their devices as cure (which is the only sales argument) the makers of the bot defender systems have to produce success reports of "detected" bots. At this point ALL types of bot defenders simply rely on a central database of avater names or UUIDs, which is filled MANUALLY (usually with the names of those criticizing the system in question) or maybe automatically with a healthy dose of discrimination (like labelling all users of text-only clients as copybots).
Remember, NO BOT DETECTOR SYSTEM CAN ACTUALLY DETECT COPYBOTS, if the coder put any effort into disguising them!
- In my opinion, this warrants some action on the side of Linden Labs, who are able to deal with the copybotting issue properly and effectively by banning the account and its alts. Only this feeling of vulnerability gives lynchmob-type self-acclaimed justice tools like Redzone or Voodoo any grounds.
Notes:
- Yes, copybotting exists. I do not want to belittle the dangers to intellectual property within SL. But there are two reasons the big players in the SL economy do not need bot protector devices: 1. They know how SL works and see that they can not protect themselves by buying placebo 2. They also know that no copybotter has the wealth of support, service and customer care that the big makers can afford.
- If you encounter someone doing copybotting, by all means AR them and inform the original maker!
- Linden Labs will if they find an item to be copied and propagated replace the item with blank "IP Replacement" objects. So basically, any copybotted item someone ends up having (maybe having bought in good faith), may suddenly end up being useless. This will again keep the orginial makers in business with the copybots not being able to make much money economically.
- The makers of those "bot defending" gadgets tend to expand the ability and focus of their devices to distract from their inherent inability to work as "bot defenders", by adding up "alts" and "griefers" into the list of evils they protect against. I will go into the details of those in my next posts, but suffice to say: that does not justify their lynchmob mentality either.
No comments:
Post a Comment