Thursday, April 19, 2012

Voodoo, reloaded

What is the fuzz about?
There are two gadgets made by Monkey Wonder and sold under the Voodoo label: "Voodoo Xploder" and "Voodoo Anti-Bot".
The latter is a pretty standard networked security device but with a central internet-based database. It used to claim it could protect you from bots, hence the name, but nowadays admits it never was actually able to do so. Its central ban list is fed by humans.
The former is a general sploder, but with the option to set it to 'verified' mode. In this mode, participants of the sploder have to 'verify' at a website before being allowed to participate. This is done to prevent 'alts' and 'bots' from participating.
Both devices share the common ban list (if sploder is set to 'anti-bot' mode).

Why is Greenzone against these gadgets?
Side note: ANY sploder works by determining a winner based on a random function, and has a payout in Linden dollars. So by the Linden's own ban on gambling, ALL sploders are illegal, compare here. But since GZ is not campaigning against wagering, but for privacy, this is not a matter we are focussing on.

Instead we are against the Voodoo sploder because:
  • First and foremost, who is or is not someone's alt is their own private business and any gadget that attempts to find that out its breaking the ToS (section 8.2.v) and CS (section 4)
  • The attempted privacy invasion is within the context of a sploder, therefor working with money as incentive, which we find dubious at best.
  • Even if the result of a positive 'alt' detection is no longer shouted in local as it used to (more research here is needed), it is easy for a social group to determine this information out of the rejected people, and at the very least is defamatory for people subject to such a rejection.
  • In the past there was numerous evidence that such 'alt' data was shared between Monkey and his friends, but Monkey since then claims he purges his IP database after a week. This has to be verified, but was a step in the right direction!
  • The 'alt detection' is done by gathering of the IP address at the verfication website, matching avatar name and IP address and comparing IP addresses. Two avatars with the same IP address = alts.
    I am certain that I do not need to point out all the issues related to IP address as identifier for an individual. We have done this over and over when Redzone was discussed. In a nutshell: same IP is no suitable indicator for two avatars being alts.
  • The 'verify' mode brings up a pop-up with a link, sending people to the registration website, if not already 'verified'. This pop-up reads ""WARNING: Voodoo will record your IP address to identify violations of TOS if you click on the link above""
    Note that this is not the only instance that Voodoo products ambigously speak of the 'TOS' and purposefully make people believe they are talking about the LindenLabs Terms of Service, but instead refer to their own Voodoo Terms of Service, which they named this way just to scam and to intimidate people.
  • "If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear, just give us your data."

Greenzone has much fewer issues with the 'Anti-Bot':
  • Any automated bot detection is a joke. It does not, period. So it is a scam at that level, but has admitted to be one and that its database is filled by humans.
  • People on the bad side of those humans (like every member of the GZ User Group, by Monkey's own threat NC) are ejected and banned, there used to be a defamatory message "... is identified as a bot and attempted to be ejected." No need to point out that this constitutes harassment and defamation, violating ToS 8.3.iv and CS section 2 regarding harassment and impeding of use.
  • There needs to be done some more research as to the privacy relevant issues regarding the adding of people here: can any owner of a Anti-Bot add people manually? Can they see who was added by whom? Like any networked security device, this has the potential to be a giant griefer tool ("I own an Anti-Bot. Do what I want or I will add you as bot and ban you from lots of SL!")
  • People on the ban list can remove themselves via the Voodoo Website (thereby giving Monkey another AVname/IP address correlation!), but there used to be a mechanism preventing people from removing themselves, if they are on Monkey's VERY bad side. Like GZ officers. More research is needed. (I have not attempted to remove myself because I like to be on this list to protect me from accidentally spending money where Voodoos are.)

Why is there such a war between GZ and Monkey Wonder?
Well, we didn't start the war...
First we were fighting factually against the privacy issues. Monkey did 'retaliate' (his own choice of words!) against GZ at every opportunity and with means GZ officers outright refuse to use. He:
  • created alts with names close to GZ officers using them for griefing and to spread false information. For example, he made an alt called 'Mlro Resident' to spread false information and grief (mind the spelling of Mlro with an lowercase L).
  • GZ officers were harassed, for example by renting the parcel next to one of Miro's shops and placing a Voodoo there who constantly attempts to eject Miro or his guests from their own land.
  • He obtained a prim originally made by Fart Admiral (likely the Greenzone HUD itself) and filled it with a script to eject Greenzone staff members. Proof:
    This is harassment and defamation of the nastiest sort!


Despite all this, I tried to bury the hatchet and contacted Monkey to discuss the issues, because I saw movement towards a direction we support (in that case, the 1 week deletion period of the IP addresses).

Serves me right, the result of my initiative is well known = the blackmail.

Surprise: in Monkey's view GZ is alternatively a well-organized army, with a clear hierarchy and responsibilities (his blackmail was the result of someone with a GZ member group tag doing something he disapproved of. I repeatedly told him that GZ is a open-join group, but he did not seem to grasp the concept. Next time I meet him I will have the Phoenix-Firestorm Supportgroup tag up, maybe he bans all members of that group as well?)
but alternatively he claims in his own notecard "The moderators have lost control, and the group is now a leaderless organisation that anyone with a grudge can join to attack others in the name of Greenzone." O hypocrites!

In a nutshell: as long as a device can be used to impede privacy, for example by attempting to identify alts, Greenzone will continue to campaign against it.

And yes, Monkey Wonder, that means you would have to abolish your 'verify' sploder mode, and of course stop your silly, immature and sometimes criminal attacks against us.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Deception and Trust

I do not understand it.

How dumb can people be, trusting a brand that hides and obfuscates their every move?

Instead of openly engage discussion as was offered by Greenzone officers repeatedly,
the Voodoo gang
- renamed their objects in-world to hide them,
- made a bunch of alts as creators of the devices like the oft-abused "Mlro" or now "Voodosl" (Get it? Alts are not allowed for others and are banned from their sploders, but THEY are of course allowed to use them... Hypocrites anyone?)
- harrassed Greenzone officers in world to the extent that Lindens had to intervene and tell them off

It seems we have to make all this more public...

Monday, November 7, 2011

Voodoo, the New Honesty

A quote from the Voodoo site over at http://voodoo-sl.com/antibot.php:

Feature List for version 2.07 :
  • There is no automated bot detection technology, as this is unreliable. Detection is now done by a team of human bot hunters.
  • [...]
  • Constantly updated bot database.
So... in other words Voodoo finally admits that they were unable to detect any bots all along, and that their database was filled by humans with people whom THEY thought looked funny. Or who they didn't like like for whatever reasons - like the whole Greenzone.

So let me amend my earlier post:

  1. Humans from the Voodoo team maintain and manually fill a database of people they don't like
  2. The Voodoo AntiBot gadget shouts publicly that those people are 'bots' (translate 'malevolent and/or thieving residents') and attempts to eject them.
  3. Voodoo and its maker have on numerous occasions defamed GZ staff and supporters directly: defamation as bots, defamation as individuals by making similarly named alts and spreading misinformation and grief with those names (look up "Mlro Resident" a response to Miro Muni), and various other events of grief and defamation.

In other words: Voodoo does not even claim it is a bot detector any more. It admits to be a griefer tool which ejects people who were deemed bots by the Voodoo team! Mind you, that team are the very same mature people who:
  • Obtained a prim originally made by Fart Admiral (likely the Greenzone HUD itself) and filled it with a script to eject Greenzone staff members.
  • Added anyone who reported a Voodoo system as "bot" into their database, usually without the chance for appeal
  • Harrassed Miro Muni multiple ways, by renting the parcel next to one of Miro's shops and placing a Voodoo there who constantly attempts to eject Miro or his guests from their own land, by making an alt called 'Mlro Resident' to spread false information and grief (mind the spelling of M*L*ro with an l) and several more.


Recommendation:
  1. Get the GZ HUD!
  2. Report Voodoo for Harassment and Griefing!
  3. Boycott Voodoo sites!

Monday, August 22, 2011

On Copybots and Copybot Defenders

It seems necessary to spend some words on what copybotting is, since there are so many devices claiming to defend against copybotting.

  1. Any viewer needs to have descriptive information about objects in-world, and the textures on the prims, including the sculpt textures if any. The viewer needs this information to be able to display the object.


  2. Starting from this, it is easily doable for a person who can code to add a few lines to one of the open source viewers, to not only display, but export this information, thus enabling the person operating this modified viewer to re-upload the textures and reconstruct the object. These are the so-called copybot viewers, or copybots.


  3. NONE of the so called bot defender systems can protect against copybotting!
    Why?
    • a perfectly legal client is changed to export textures and prim data, WITHOUT in any way changing how this client reacts to Second Life. So its exporting is not detactable in-world.
    • a bot detector placed in a shop is utterly unable to prevent any scanning taking place ELSEWHERE in SL (clothing on av's encountered anywhere in SL, objects rezzed somewhere...)


  4. In consequence this means that ALL bot protector or bot defendor systems that are bought and placed in shops, only serve to calm the fears of the content creators in SL, fearing copybots. Now, don't misunderstand me, copybotting is a reality. But this exaggerated fear, where does it come from? In most cases this fear is propagated by the marketing of the bot defender systems themselves! They generate an imaginary of hordes of copybotters intent to steal the creator's work. In fact, this is making business with the fear of the ill-informed.


    How else can be explained a bot protector system in a clothing shop where none of the clothing exists rezzed, but only inside vendors? Without it rezzed in world, it can not be copybotted. Remember, the copybot viewer only exports the very information ANY viewer needs to have, to be able to display the item...
    (Which makes a prim's CONTENT, like all scripting and everything else inside a prim's inventory immune to copybotting, by the way.)


  5. To keep the fear alive and present their devices as cure (which is the only sales argument) the makers of the bot defender systems have to produce success reports of "detected" bots. At this point ALL types of bot defenders simply rely on a central database of avater names or UUIDs, which is filled MANUALLY (usually with the names of those criticizing the system in question) or maybe automatically with a healthy dose of discrimination (like labelling all users of text-only clients as copybots).

    Remember, NO BOT DETECTOR SYSTEM CAN ACTUALLY DETECT COPYBOTS, if the coder put any effort into disguising them!


  6. In my opinion, this warrants some action on the side of Linden Labs, who are able to deal with the copybotting issue properly and effectively by banning the account and its alts. Only this feeling of vulnerability gives lynchmob-type self-acclaimed justice tools like Redzone or Voodoo any grounds.

Notes:
  • Yes, copybotting exists. I do not want to belittle the dangers to intellectual property within SL. But there are two reasons the big players in the SL economy do not need bot protector devices: 1. They know how SL works and see that they can not protect themselves by buying placebo 2. They also know that no copybotter has the wealth of support, service and customer care that the big makers can afford.
  • If you encounter someone doing copybotting, by all means AR them and inform the original maker!
  • Linden Labs will if they find an item to be copied and propagated replace the item with blank "IP Replacement" objects. So basically, any copybotted item someone ends up having (maybe having bought in good faith), may suddenly end up being useless. This will again keep the orginial makers in business with the copybots not being able to make much money economically.
  • The makers of those "bot defending" gadgets tend to expand the ability and focus of their devices to distract from their inherent inability to work as "bot defenders", by adding up "alts" and "griefers" into the list of evils they protect against. I will go into the details of those in my next posts, but suffice to say: that does not justify their lynchmob mentality either.

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Voodoo...

Dear Reader,

there seems to be some questions as to the Voodoo products, so I would like to summarize:

  1. There are two Voodoo products, a sploder and a 'bot protector', made by "Monkey Wonder".

  2. The 'bot protector' does not protect against bots. It claims to, but doesn't.
    ( No known method exists to properly detect bots. All bot defender systems of all makers only feed of the fears they themselves propagate.
    Oh, and maybe 'catch' some people who use viewers not known to defender system makers, like text viewers, which are then labelled as bots. )


    It does however ban and eject people from a central database / blacklist.

    (the latter confirmed by Monkey on the JIRA
    and in their own product description:
    ✔ Simple set up, no configuration.
    ✔ The device scans a 96m range every 20 seconds for nearby avatars.
    ✔ The list of avatars is sent to our central web server.
    ✔ If any of the avatars received is present in our bot list, their avatar key is sent back to the device.
    ✔ Any offenders that are received by the device are immediately banned and sent home.
    )

  3. The sploder requires people to verify on their website, which results in an IP address/username connection.
    This is done with the incentive of SL money (= participation in sploder actions)
    (confirmed multiple times, eg. by Monkey on the JIRA)

  4. Both devices also attempt to gather the most recent IP of people in-world: the sploder of those who touch it to participate, the 'bot protector' continously, both by using the known media hole.
    (confirmed by Monkey Wonder in Greenzone Group chat, but denied by him on other forums, so that is something he may not want to be public knowledge.)

    Additionally, the 'bot protector' logs all AVs scanned by them, the purpose of that data being unclear, but constitutes data harvesting.
    ( see their own product description:
    ✔ The device scans a 96m range every 20 seconds for nearby avatars.
    ✔ The list of avatars is sent to our central web server.[...]
    )


  5. The amorphous "Voodoo Team" has access to the gathered data in the central database.

  6. The 'bot protector' systems ban and eject 'bots' ( unclear how that is determined, but see #7 )
    and 'alts' ( = people with matching IPs, despite the well known issues with IP as means to identify an individual).
    Also 'bots' and 'alts' are prohibited from participating in sploders.
    ( confirmed by Monkey Wonder in Greenzone group chat, JIRA, product description etc.)

  7. People speaking out against Voodoo are manually entered as 'bots'
    ( confirmed by the Very Vocal Voodoo Puppet "LavitaLoca Vita":
    "And regarding what you said before, yes, we have begun to add people manually, who have made defamatory statements toward us or our sploder or antibot customers, that is true"
    and by Monkey Wonder himself:
    NOTICE TO EVERYONE: We have taken on a new initiative to target some of the individuals responsible for spreading false information in an attempt to defame Voodoo and damage the business. Anyone found doing this publicly will be banned and locked.
    )


  8. Monkey has started a hatred campaign against Greenzone from the moment they were inquiring. His cronies are constantly griefing Greenzone group chat.


Analysis:
  • IP/Avatar correlations, including but not limited to alternate account informations, are gathered (by several means), used by items in world, and are shared with a group of SL residents (at the very least the 'team'),
    violating ToS 8.3.i and CS section 4 regarding privacy and data harvesting

  • The devices' data are subject to human manipulation and biased entry, resulting in defamation for those being entered,
    violating ToS 8.3.iv and CS section 2 regarding harassment and impeding of use


=> Voodoo Sploders and Voodoo Bot Protectors are in violation of the ToS, and I recommend to report them on sight.

Monday, April 18, 2011

A true Badge of Honour...

Thanks to Azure Twine and Anastasia who located this, we found the (horribly overpriced) shop of Vasilisa Shilova (former love interest of zFire Xue)... and found out that we were banned from that shop, despite never ever raising a hand against her.

So why were we banned?

A short look at the banlist of the parcel revealed, that all officers of the Greenzone group plus two friends of Win and Anastasia were there.

None of us ever went there before... so why were we banned if not for this connection as fighters for privacy and Greenzone.

So it seems like a big badge of honour!
I preset to you: zFire's most hated enemies!

  • Anastasia Howlett
  • Aria Sparta
  • Azure Twine
  • brock Enyo
  • Fart Admiral
  • Jelena Kiranov
  • Lella Demonia
  • Unya Tigerfish
  • Vexy Juran
  • WinthorpeFoghorn Zinnemann





Wednesday, March 16, 2011

VICTORY!

Zfire Xue has been banned from Second Life! Redzone has been banned from Second Life!

I am deeply humbled by the momentum this movement has achieved. I am humbled by the voices that made themselves heard, demanding nothing more and nothing less than what is their human right. Community of Second Life, I am in awe.

This now is really a victory, a victory not only for Greenzone, not only for those fighting against Redzone, but a victory for all of Second Life. Tomorrow is St Patrick's Day! Let us all celebrate this day as the day of freedom from oppression.

TOMORROW IS OUR MUTUAL GREEN DAY!