Thursday, July 28, 2011

Voodoo...

Dear Reader,

there seems to be some questions as to the Voodoo products, so I would like to summarize:

  1. There are two Voodoo products, a sploder and a 'bot protector', made by "Monkey Wonder".

  2. The 'bot protector' does not protect against bots. It claims to, but doesn't.
    ( No known method exists to properly detect bots. All bot defender systems of all makers only feed of the fears they themselves propagate.
    Oh, and maybe 'catch' some people who use viewers not known to defender system makers, like text viewers, which are then labelled as bots. )


    It does however ban and eject people from a central database / blacklist.

    (the latter confirmed by Monkey on the JIRA
    and in their own product description:
    ✔ Simple set up, no configuration.
    ✔ The device scans a 96m range every 20 seconds for nearby avatars.
    ✔ The list of avatars is sent to our central web server.
    ✔ If any of the avatars received is present in our bot list, their avatar key is sent back to the device.
    ✔ Any offenders that are received by the device are immediately banned and sent home.
    )

  3. The sploder requires people to verify on their website, which results in an IP address/username connection.
    This is done with the incentive of SL money (= participation in sploder actions)
    (confirmed multiple times, eg. by Monkey on the JIRA)

  4. Both devices also attempt to gather the most recent IP of people in-world: the sploder of those who touch it to participate, the 'bot protector' continously, both by using the known media hole.
    (confirmed by Monkey Wonder in Greenzone Group chat, but denied by him on other forums, so that is something he may not want to be public knowledge.)

    Additionally, the 'bot protector' logs all AVs scanned by them, the purpose of that data being unclear, but constitutes data harvesting.
    ( see their own product description:
    ✔ The device scans a 96m range every 20 seconds for nearby avatars.
    ✔ The list of avatars is sent to our central web server.[...]
    )


  5. The amorphous "Voodoo Team" has access to the gathered data in the central database.

  6. The 'bot protector' systems ban and eject 'bots' ( unclear how that is determined, but see #7 )
    and 'alts' ( = people with matching IPs, despite the well known issues with IP as means to identify an individual).
    Also 'bots' and 'alts' are prohibited from participating in sploders.
    ( confirmed by Monkey Wonder in Greenzone group chat, JIRA, product description etc.)

  7. People speaking out against Voodoo are manually entered as 'bots'
    ( confirmed by the Very Vocal Voodoo Puppet "LavitaLoca Vita":
    "And regarding what you said before, yes, we have begun to add people manually, who have made defamatory statements toward us or our sploder or antibot customers, that is true"
    and by Monkey Wonder himself:
    NOTICE TO EVERYONE: We have taken on a new initiative to target some of the individuals responsible for spreading false information in an attempt to defame Voodoo and damage the business. Anyone found doing this publicly will be banned and locked.
    )


  8. Monkey has started a hatred campaign against Greenzone from the moment they were inquiring. His cronies are constantly griefing Greenzone group chat.


Analysis:
  • IP/Avatar correlations, including but not limited to alternate account informations, are gathered (by several means), used by items in world, and are shared with a group of SL residents (at the very least the 'team'),
    violating ToS 8.3.i and CS section 4 regarding privacy and data harvesting

  • The devices' data are subject to human manipulation and biased entry, resulting in defamation for those being entered,
    violating ToS 8.3.iv and CS section 2 regarding harassment and impeding of use


=> Voodoo Sploders and Voodoo Bot Protectors are in violation of the ToS, and I recommend to report them on sight.

Monday, April 18, 2011

A true Badge of Honour...

Thanks to Azure Twine and Anastasia who located this, we found the (horribly overpriced) shop of Vasilisa Shilova (former love interest of zFire Xue)... and found out that we were banned from that shop, despite never ever raising a hand against her.

So why were we banned?

A short look at the banlist of the parcel revealed, that all officers of the Greenzone group plus two friends of Win and Anastasia were there.

None of us ever went there before... so why were we banned if not for this connection as fighters for privacy and Greenzone.

So it seems like a big badge of honour!
I preset to you: zFire's most hated enemies!

  • Anastasia Howlett
  • Aria Sparta
  • Azure Twine
  • brock Enyo
  • Fart Admiral
  • Jelena Kiranov
  • Lella Demonia
  • Unya Tigerfish
  • Vexy Juran
  • WinthorpeFoghorn Zinnemann





Wednesday, March 16, 2011

VICTORY!

Zfire Xue has been banned from Second Life! Redzone has been banned from Second Life!

I am deeply humbled by the momentum this movement has achieved. I am humbled by the voices that made themselves heard, demanding nothing more and nothing less than what is their human right. Community of Second Life, I am in awe.

This now is really a victory, a victory not only for Greenzone, not only for those fighting against Redzone, but a victory for all of Second Life. Tomorrow is St Patrick's Day! Let us all celebrate this day as the day of freedom from oppression.

TOMORROW IS OUR MUTUAL GREEN DAY!

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

A Small Step for Second Life - a Huge Plunge for Redzone!

Soft Linden posted on the JIRA:


Hey, all. I got the go-ahead to give an update on zF Red Zone specifically. Again, thank you for the ARs with specific info about violations. These have been very helpful for letting Lindens know what's going on.

Tuesday morning, we removed zF Red Zone from the Marketplace for a second time. We removed the in-world vendor distributing the item as well. We determined that zF Red Zone was still in violation of our Terms of Service and Community Standards.

We asked for removal by no later than today of all zF Red Zone functionality that discloses any alternate account names. That is, even if consent is asked, the service may not act on the consent. In addition, we asked for removal by no later than Friday of the interface for and any remaining implementation of the zF Red Zone consent mechanism because it does not comply with our policies. If these updates are not made, we will take appropriate steps to remedy the violations.

As before, we appreciate your help in keeping an eye on content. If you find that any merchant's product is not in compliance with our TOS or our Community Standards, please file an abuse report about the product. Do this even if you filed against a previous version. Include a specific explanation of what you believe is a violation, and ideally select and report the in-world object at issue in case it behaves differently than what's in the Marketplace. Before reporting, make sure you have first-hand knowledge of the issue. Support can best react if you explain specific steps to reproduce or confirm a violation.

This will be the death sentence for Redzone, but not for the illegitimate children it was spawning in its wake, so the fight is not over.

But the gods have spoken, and they have spoken mightily!

Thursday, February 17, 2011

The beginning of the end?

As of today, zf Redzone is no longer listed on SL Marketplace. The items in-world are still present, though, so likely they are still sold at least at his shop. But I am happy to see SOME action at least...

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Apologies are in order - I have gone a bit too far.

As justified as my aim to devalue the Redzone database still is in my eyes, I did not foresee the consequences for those caught between braindead Redzone owners and my attempts.

My prank may have raised some awareness to Redzone's flaws, but also a lot of anger. And the more, I was surprised myself how many people in fact had configured their Redzones to automatically ban.

Had I known this I had not performed my prank like this, as indeed innocents were affected.

I therefor offer my sincere apologize to those that were the innocent casualties in this.

What if Linden Labs is unwilling to protect your privacy?

What if your data has akready been collected by the spyware?

Well, I have taken some steps.

I am randomly linking people owning Redzones and people on their sims and on their ban lists, so that Redzone thinks them to be alts.

Why am I doing this?

Well, two reasons.

First, the privacy issue.
Redzone is a clear breach not only of ToS, but of US privacy laws. US law states that the criminal act of "invasion of privacy" takes place when there is (for example):
  • Public disclosure of private facts (my alts are my private matter, and only mine)
or
  • False light: the publication of facts which place a person in a false light, even though the facts themselves may not be defamatory. (And being labelled alt of someone is a false light, as the IP gathering is less than perfect.)
There always have been false positives and real positives. But to protect the privacy of anyone in this database, I am making the data unusable for any alt detection purposes.
Mind that I am in no way limiting zf Redzone's "Copybot detection" ability (which is a joke). Also I am in no way limiting its security feature of  being able to ban or eject people (like a lot of gadgets can do, and which I have no problem with).

By making the data (blatantly) unreliable, I am just making this database of alts more and more worthless.

Second, the moral issue.

Banning people because someone (or even a tool) claims they are evil because they are (or in some cases even just because they HAVE alts) is like discriminating against people of their black skin colour. Well, take care, you may awake and be painted black yourself.


Some more points of minor importance:
  • I have been accused of messing in the functioning of sims, or even attacking or griefing sims. Well, I did not. I did not touch a single item in world and did not mess with the operating of any SL server or any LL asset. I just added names to a database outside of SL. That the spyware "zf Redzone" was set to autofire and eject anyone who matches someone zFire Xue deems "evil" is really not my doing. The Greenzone team has warned a lot about the dangers of false positives in these data. In most cases I have not even visited the sims that now claim to have been attacked and griefed...
  • I am not a copybotter (although I am sure zFire Xue will claim that I am, I am sure. *yawns* Well then, when and where have I been copybotting, zFire?). I highly value and respect the creativity everyone in the creating community is putting into their products.
  • I am not an alt of a copybotter. I actually don't have any alts at all, except an old retired one I never used.
  • I am alone responsible for my actions, not a certain famous BDSM blogger who was being falsely accused as being the cause for this.
  • I am not "like those Redzone people" myself. The major difference is that I am not gathering or sharing any private data. I am just writing an avatar's name and its UUID into a database. That I do so with several avatars, and do so from the same computer, which happens to have the effect that zf Redzone thinks these are alts, I have no control over. I do not even share the people's real IP address.
  •  zFire knows of my stunts at least since Feb 9th 2011 but is hushing them down. Several people reported on his forums, but the threads miraculously disappear very quickly. Aww.... zFire is not helping you with the chaos your expensive toy is causing? Or the incorrect data in his database?
  • What I am doing is not illegal... I am not modifying any data in world, I do not operate any sim-affecting device inside SL, I did not "hack" zFire's database or his computers. His database is open to all.
  • I strongly recommend that Redzone owners disable the "ban alt on sight" feature.
  • If someone wants to play the same game as I do, contact me in-world and I tell you how to do so.
  • What I am doing is protection of privacy by watering the data. Perfectly legal passive resistance, until LL decides to plug the bug, when it will no longer be necessary.