Thursday, February 17, 2011

The beginning of the end?

As of today, zf Redzone is no longer listed on SL Marketplace. The items in-world are still present, though, so likely they are still sold at least at his shop. But I am happy to see SOME action at least...

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Apologies are in order - I have gone a bit too far.

As justified as my aim to devalue the Redzone database still is in my eyes, I did not foresee the consequences for those caught between braindead Redzone owners and my attempts.

My prank may have raised some awareness to Redzone's flaws, but also a lot of anger. And the more, I was surprised myself how many people in fact had configured their Redzones to automatically ban.

Had I known this I had not performed my prank like this, as indeed innocents were affected.

I therefor offer my sincere apologize to those that were the innocent casualties in this.

What if Linden Labs is unwilling to protect your privacy?

What if your data has akready been collected by the spyware?

Well, I have taken some steps.

I am randomly linking people owning Redzones and people on their sims and on their ban lists, so that Redzone thinks them to be alts.

Why am I doing this?

Well, two reasons.

First, the privacy issue.
Redzone is a clear breach not only of ToS, but of US privacy laws. US law states that the criminal act of "invasion of privacy" takes place when there is (for example):
  • Public disclosure of private facts (my alts are my private matter, and only mine)
or
  • False light: the publication of facts which place a person in a false light, even though the facts themselves may not be defamatory. (And being labelled alt of someone is a false light, as the IP gathering is less than perfect.)
There always have been false positives and real positives. But to protect the privacy of anyone in this database, I am making the data unusable for any alt detection purposes.
Mind that I am in no way limiting zf Redzone's "Copybot detection" ability (which is a joke). Also I am in no way limiting its security feature of  being able to ban or eject people (like a lot of gadgets can do, and which I have no problem with).

By making the data (blatantly) unreliable, I am just making this database of alts more and more worthless.

Second, the moral issue.

Banning people because someone (or even a tool) claims they are evil because they are (or in some cases even just because they HAVE alts) is like discriminating against people of their black skin colour. Well, take care, you may awake and be painted black yourself.


Some more points of minor importance:
  • I have been accused of messing in the functioning of sims, or even attacking or griefing sims. Well, I did not. I did not touch a single item in world and did not mess with the operating of any SL server or any LL asset. I just added names to a database outside of SL. That the spyware "zf Redzone" was set to autofire and eject anyone who matches someone zFire Xue deems "evil" is really not my doing. The Greenzone team has warned a lot about the dangers of false positives in these data. In most cases I have not even visited the sims that now claim to have been attacked and griefed...
  • I am not a copybotter (although I am sure zFire Xue will claim that I am, I am sure. *yawns* Well then, when and where have I been copybotting, zFire?). I highly value and respect the creativity everyone in the creating community is putting into their products.
  • I am not an alt of a copybotter. I actually don't have any alts at all, except an old retired one I never used.
  • I am alone responsible for my actions, not a certain famous BDSM blogger who was being falsely accused as being the cause for this.
  • I am not "like those Redzone people" myself. The major difference is that I am not gathering or sharing any private data. I am just writing an avatar's name and its UUID into a database. That I do so with several avatars, and do so from the same computer, which happens to have the effect that zf Redzone thinks these are alts, I have no control over. I do not even share the people's real IP address.
  •  zFire knows of my stunts at least since Feb 9th 2011 but is hushing them down. Several people reported on his forums, but the threads miraculously disappear very quickly. Aww.... zFire is not helping you with the chaos your expensive toy is causing? Or the incorrect data in his database?
  • What I am doing is not illegal... I am not modifying any data in world, I do not operate any sim-affecting device inside SL, I did not "hack" zFire's database or his computers. His database is open to all.
  • I strongly recommend that Redzone owners disable the "ban alt on sight" feature.
  • If someone wants to play the same game as I do, contact me in-world and I tell you how to do so.
  • What I am doing is protection of privacy by watering the data. Perfectly legal passive resistance, until LL decides to plug the bug, when it will no longer be necessary.